Is your player’s mind holding back their game? Take the free 2-minute Mental Game Quiz →

For players & parents

Great in practice. Gone in games. Here’s why.

By Coach Sandy Cohan · 6-minute read

It’s the most common thing parents tell me on a first call: “In practice, he’s one of the best players out there. In games, he disappears.” Same player. Same hands. Same legs. Completely different results.

If that sounds like your player, here’s what I want you to know: this is almost never a skill problem. It’s a mindset problem. And mindset can be trained.

What changes between practice and games

In practice, there’s nothing on the line. Mistakes are free. Players play on instinct, try things and react. In games, a few things change at once:

  • Consequences show up: the scoreboard, ice time, the coach’s opinion, parents in the stands.
  • The goal quietly shifts from “make plays” to “don’t make mistakes.”
  • Thinking replaces reacting: the player starts analyzing instead of playing.
Players who play not to lose usually end up playing not to be noticed.

When a player is afraid of mistakes, they make the safe play, hesitate for a split second, and avoid the puck instead of hunting it. In a game this fast, that split second is everything.

Confidence isn’t a feeling. It’s a choice.

Many players wait to feel confident before they play confidently. That’s backwards. Confidence is built from preparation, actions and decisions: choosing to attack, to want the puck, to compete, even when the feeling isn’t there yet.

Four ways to close the gap

  1. Let the hockey happen. Trust the preparation. Practice is where you think; games are where you play.
  2. Build a reset. Every player makes mistakes. The ones who move up have a quick way to let them go. Recognize it, ask “What’s important now?”, and refocus on the next shift.
  3. Measure what you control. Stop judging games by points. Rate effort, compete level, decisions and speed. Those you can improve every single game.
  4. Collect proof. After every game, write down one thing done well. Belief grows from evidence, and after a month your player has 30 pieces of it.

When it’s time for more help

If the gap between practice and games has been there for a season or more, it usually means something deeper is going on: pressure, fear of mistakes or a confidence leak your player can’t see yet. That’s exactly what one-on-one coaching is designed to uncover and fix.

Find out where your player stands

Take the free Mental Game Quiz

10 questions, 2 minutes. Get a score across confidence, resets, pressure, focus and coachability, and the free tool built for your player’s biggest gap.

Take the quiz

Or schedule a free introductory call and tell me what you’re seeing. We’ll figure out what’s holding your player back.

Free · Every week

The Mental Edge Weekly

One tool to try, one story from the rink, and what to say on the ride home. Straight from Coach Sandy, every week. Unsubscribe anytime.

Let’s talk about your player

Always in your corner.

A free, no-pressure introductory call with Coach Sandy. You’ll leave with a clear picture of what’s holding your player back and what would help, whether you work with us or not.

Free intro call Quiz